DIAMOND STATE TEA PARTY
September 08, 2011
AP
By Michael Boskin, WSJ
...an $825 billion
stimulus package; the Public-Private Investment Partnership to buy
toxic assets from the banks; "cash for clunkers"; the home-buyers
credit; record spending and budget deficits and exploding debt; the auto
bailouts; five versions of foreclosure relief; numerous lifelines to
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac; financial regulation and health-care reform;
energy subsidies, mandates and moratoria; and constant demands for
higher tax rates on "the rich" and businesses.
Consider the
direct results of the Obama programs. A few have performed better than
expected—e.g., the auto bailouts, although a rapid private bankruptcy
was preferable and GM and Chrysler are not yet denationalized successes.
But the failed stimulus bill cost an astounding $280,000 per job—over
five times median pay—by the administration's inflated estimates of jobs
"created or saved," and much more using more realistic estimates.
Cash
for clunkers cost $3 billion, just to shift car sales forward a few
months. The Public-Private Investment Partnership, despite cheap federal
loans, generated 3% of the $1 trillion claimed, and toxic assets still
hobble some financial institutions. The Dodd-Frank financial reform law
institutionalized "too big to fail" amid greater concentration of
banking assets and mortgages in Fannie and Freddie. The foreclosure
relief program permanently modified only a small percentage of the four
million mortgages the president promised. And even Mr. Obama now admits
that the shovels weren't ready in all those "shovel-ready" stimulus
projects.
Perpetually overpromising and underdelivering is not
remotely good enough, not even for government work. No corporate CEO
could survive such a clear history of failure. The economic records set
on Mr. Obama's watch really are historic (see nearby table). These
include the first downgrade of sovereign U.S. debt in American history,
and, relative to GDP, the highest federal spending in U.S. history save
the peak years of World War II, plus the highest federal debt since just
after World War II.
The employment picture doesn't look any
better. The fraction of the population working is the lowest since 1983.
Long-term unemployment is by far the highest since the Great
Depression. Job growth during the first two years of recovery after a
severe recession is the slowest in postwar history.
Moreover, the
home-ownership rate is the lowest since 1965 and foreclosures are at a
post-Depression high. And perhaps most ominously, the share of Americans
paying income taxes is the lowest in the modern era, while dependency
on government is the highest in U.S. history.
That's quite a record, although not what Mr. Obama and his supporters had in mind when they pronounced this presidency historic.